The Art of the Occasion: Lady Gaga and the Diplomacy of the Global Stage

I. Introduction: The Question of the Occasion

When Lady Gaga emerged on a grand staircase by the Seine to open the Paris 2024 Olympic Games, the immediate spectacle was one of dazzling, feather-adorned showmanship.¹

Yet, the performance prompted a question far more profound than what was immediately visible.

The query, “Why did Lady Gaga perform at the Olympics?”, transcends the logistical.

It is not an inquiry about scheduling or contracts but one of strategy, artistry, and identity.

For an artist of her stature, such a performance is never merely a gig; it is a statement.

The appearance in Paris must be understood as a culminating moment in a career defined by the masterful navigation of the world’s most scrutinized stages.

It represents a carefully calibrated act of cultural engagement by a legacy artist whose understanding of such platforms has been shaped by a decade of high-stakes performances.

To fully comprehend the significance of the Paris ceremony, one must view it not in isolation, but as the latest chapter in a compelling trilogy of spectacles.

The central thesis of this analysis is that the Paris performance represents a sophisticated evolution in Lady Gaga’s approach to artistic diplomacy—a strategy honed through the triumphs of patriotic pageantry and, more importantly, the ethical complexities of prior engagements.

By examining her headlining performance at the 2017 Super Bowl LI halftime show and, most crucially, her controversial appearance at the 2015 inaugural European Games in Baku, Azerbaijan, a clear trajectory emerges.

This comparative framework reveals the development of an artist who has learned to wield her immense cultural power with increasing nuance and precision.

The performance on the Seine was not simply an opening act; it was the result of a long education in the art of the global occasion.

II. Deconstructing Paris: A Meticulous Homage to a Host Nation

The Paris 2024 performance was a masterclass in cultural deference and artistic specificity.

It was an act designed not to conquer the global stage with an artist’s own brand, but to honor the host nation with a deeply researched and respectfully rendered tribute.

Every element, from the song choice to the costuming, was calibrated to “warm the heart of France”.²

A. The Spectacle on the Seine: Staging, Aesthetics, and Intent

The setting itself signaled a historic departure.

For the first time, the Olympic Opening Ceremony unfolded not within the confines of a stadium but along the iconic waterway of the Seine.¹

Lady Gaga’s stage was a large staircase, its design inspired by the architecture of the Grand Palais, placing her performance squarely within the physical and cultural landscape of Paris.¹

She was accompanied by a troupe of 10 dancers and 17 musicians, her entrance a piece of classic showmanship: initially concealed behind a phalanx of large pink feathers, she was dramatically revealed to begin her number.¹

The performance was distinguished by its profound attention to authentic French artistic detail.

It was a direct collaboration with the House of Dior, which created custom costumes featuring naturally molted feathers, a nod to both the song’s theme and ethical sourcing.³

Further demonstrating a commitment to historical texture, the production rented pom-poms from the archives of Le Lido, the legendary Parisian cabaret theater.³

This was not a generic appropriation of “French style” but a specific engagement with its material history.

In her own statements following the event, Lady Gaga articulated this intent with clarity.

She expressed her gratitude for the invitation from the Olympics organizing committee and underscored her desire to “celebrate French art and music”.²

She spoke of having studied “French choreography that put a modern twist on a French classic,” revealing a conscious effort to position herself as a respectful guest and a student of the culture she was there to honor.³

This careful framing—as an invited artist paying tribute—was a deliberate act of diplomacy, setting a tone of reverence rather than self-promotion.

B. Le Choix de la Chanson: The Cultural Politics of “Mon Truc en Plumes”

The selection of “Mon Truc en Plumes” (“My Thing with Feathers”) was perhaps the most telling decision of the entire performance.

Eschewing more predictable and globally recognized French anthems, the choice of this 1961 song, made famous by the French ballerina and cabaret star Zizi Jeanmaire, was an act of deep cultural specificity.¹

The song is a quintessential piece of French cabaret—playful, witty, and sensually suggestive.

Its lyrics celebrate the power of performance and illusion, with lines like, “Rien dans les mains, tout dans l’coup de reins” (“Nothing in the hands, everything in the movement of the lower back”), capturing an ethos of sophisticated, self-aware seduction.⁶

These themes resonate deeply with both the history of French cabaret and Lady Gaga’s own artistic persona.

The performance was a direct and detailed homage to Jeanmaire, who had introduced the song to American audiences on a 1965 episode of The Ed Sullivan Show.⁵

Critics noted that Gaga channeled Jeanmaire’s “aesthetic, costuming, and vocal intonation,” demonstrating a level of research that transformed the performance from a simple cover into a scholarly tribute.⁵

Gaga herself highlighted a serendipitous personal connection, noting that Jeanmaire had starred in Cole Porter’s musical

Anything Goes, which was the title of Gaga’s first collaborative jazz album with Tony Bennett.³

This connection, however coincidental, allowed her to weave her own artistic history into the tribute, creating a bridge between her work and that of the French icon she was honoring.

By choosing this song, Lady Gaga was not just singing in French; she was engaging with a specific lineage of French performance Art.

C. The Rain-Checked Reality: Liveness, Mediation, and Audience Reception

Despite the meticulous planning, the performance was ultimately shaped by an uncontrollable force: the weather.

Due to rain, organizers deemed the multi-level stage, situated near the water, “too dangerous” for performers, particularly for Lady Gaga in high heels.²

The decision was made to cancel the live segment and instead pre-record the number late that afternoon.

Consequently, both the global television audience and the spectators in attendance watched the performance on screens.²

This logistical necessity created a jarring experiential disconnect for the live audience.

Attendees who had paid as much as €180 for their tickets were met with an empty, rain-slicked stage while the pre-recorded performance played.

This led to audible “boos” and expressions of disappointment from the crowd.²

Lady Gaga herself reportedly remained on-site to watch the broadcast of her own mediated performance before departing, a poignant image of an artist separated from her own work by circumstance.²

This incident, while accidental, serves as a powerful meta-commentary on the nature of the modern global spectacle.

The Olympic Opening Ceremony is a paradigmatic mega-event, an occasion designed and produced primarily for a broadcast audience numbering in the billions.

When a force of nature intervened, the organizers and the artist were faced with a choice: prioritize the authentic, in-the-moment experience of the physically present audience, with all its potential risks and imperfections, or prioritize the flawless, polished product for the global broadcast.

The decision to pre-record reveals the implicit hierarchy of viewership in such events.

The global television audience, for whom the spectacle is always already a mediated image, took precedence over the live spectators.

The performance, intended as a live interaction with the city of Paris and its people, was transformed into pure media content, a perfect television moment that existed nowhere in real-time.

This unintended outcome starkly illustrates the inherent tension between liveness and the hyper-produced, risk-averse nature of contemporary global ceremonies.

III. The Global Stage as Canvas: A Trilogy of Spectacles

The strategic depth of the Paris performance becomes fully apparent only when placed in conversation with two of Lady Gaga’s other seminal appearances at major sporting events.

These earlier performances, one a declaration of personal artistic power and the other an exercise in idealism fraught with political peril, provide the essential context for understanding her evolution as a global performer.

A. Patriotism and Pop Power: The Super Bowl LI Halftime Show (2017)

Lady Gaga’s 2017 Super Bowl LI halftime show was an act of artistic coronation.

In a rare move for the event, she headlined alone, with no special guests, placing the entire focus on her own formidable catalog and stage presence.⁸

The setlist was a high-energy medley of her greatest hits—”Poker Face,” “Born This Way,” “Just Dance,” “Bad Romance”—a powerful consolidation of her brand as a pop icon.⁸

This was not an act of homage to a host city or culture; it was a declaration of her own cultural dominance.

The performance was also a masterclass in subtle political messaging on America’s largest stage.

It began with a pre-recorded segment from the roof of the stadium, where Gaga sang a medley of “God Bless America” and Woody Guthrie’s populist anthem “This Land Is Your Land,” before reciting the final lines of the Pledge of Allegiance: “One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all”.⁸

In the politically charged atmosphere following the 2016 U.S. presidential election, this opening was widely interpreted as a quiet but firm statement on unity and inclusion.⁸

The inclusion of her anthem “Born This Way” was an unambiguous and powerful affirmation of LGBTQ+ rights broadcast to over 100 million viewers.⁸

Critically and commercially, the show was an unmitigated triumph.

It was lauded for its energy, technical innovation (it marked the first use of a drone swarm in a television broadcast), and sheer showmanship.⁸

Media outlets cited it as one of the greatest halftime shows in history, cementing her status as a “legacy artist”.⁸

The performance triggered a massive surge in her music sales, with her then-current album,

Joanne, rocketing up the charts.⁸

The Super Bowl was an American power play.

Lady Gaga used the platform to project her own message, her own music, and her own power onto the national consciousness, defining the moment on her own terms.

B. Idealism in a Contested Space: The 2015 European Games in Baku

Two years before the Super Bowl, Lady Gaga undertook a performance that stands as a critical and cautionary counterpoint.

At the opening ceremony of the inaugural European Games in Baku, Azerbaijan, she delivered a stripped-down, emotionally resonant piano-led cover of John Lennon’s “Imagine”.⁹

The performance itself was widely praised, showcasing her raw vocal talent in a minimalist setting that silenced the stadium.⁹

However, the artistic gesture was catastrophically undermined by its political context.

The 2015 Baku Games were held against the backdrop of a severe and escalating human rights crisis.

The Azerbaijani government, led by President Ilham Aliyev, was engaged in what Human Rights Watch described as “the worst crackdown the country has seen in the post-Soviet era”.¹²

Dozens of journalists, human rights defenders, and political activists were imprisoned on fabricated charges, including prominent figures like the investigative journalist Khadija Ismayilova and the activist Rasul Jafarov, who had been organizing a “Sport for Rights” campaign to highlight abuses ahead of the games.¹³

International human rights organizations like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch widely condemned the games as a “whitewash” attempt—a multi-billion-dollar effort by the oil-rich autocratic state to use a major sporting event to project a modern, progressive image while brutally crushing internal dissent.¹³

The regime’s intolerance for scrutiny was absolute: journalists from outlets including

The Guardian were banned from entering the country, and Amnesty International was forced to cancel a planned visit.¹²

This strategy of repression and “beautification” mirrored the government’s actions during the 2012 Eurovision Song Contest, also hosted in Baku.¹⁴

The performance of “Imagine” in this specific environment created a moment of profound and unsettling irony.

The song, a utopian anthem calling for a world with “no greed or hunger” and a “brotherhood of man,” was delivered at an event designed to burnish the image of a corrupt, kleptocratic regime.⁹

The call for peace and unity was made in a nation actively persecuting its citizens for the crime of free expression.¹³

Regardless of the artist’s personal intent, the performance became functionally inseparable from the state’s propaganda project.

The universalist message of the song was not a challenge to the regime; it was co-opted by it, its idealism providing a veneer of high-minded culture to a deeply repressive political enterprise.

The Baku performance illustrates the acute ethical peril an artist faces on the global stage, where a message of peace can be weaponized to obscure acts of oppression.

C. Table 1: Comparative Analysis of Lady Gaga’s Major Sporting Event Performances

The strategic evolution of Lady Gaga’s approach to these high-stakes performances is starkly illustrated when their core components are analyzed side-by-side.

The following table synthesizes the key metrics of each event, revealing a clear shift in methodology from personal brand projection and universalist idealism to culturally specific diplomacy.

Metric	Paris 2024 Olympic Games	Super Bowl LI (2017)	Baku 2015 European Games
Song Choice & Rationale	“Mon Truc en Plumes” (Zizi Jeanmaire). A specific, researched homage to French cabaret culture.	Medley of her own hits (“Poker Face,” “Born This Way,” etc.). A consolidation of her personal brand and artistic catalog.	“Imagine” (John Lennon). A universal anthem of peace and unity.
Staging & Aesthetics	Cultural homage: Dior costumes, Le Lido props, Grand Palais-inspired set. Focus on French artistic history.	Personal spectacle: High-tech drones, signature choreography, football-inspired costumes. Focus on her own iconography.	Minimalist elegance: Artist at a flower-draped piano. Focus on raw vocal performance.
Stated Intent vs. Implied Message	Intent: To honor France.3	Message: A demonstration of cultural respect and sophisticated artistic diplomacy.	Intent: To entertain and unite.8	Message: A declaration of her own cultural power and a subtle affirmation of American inclusivity.	Intent: To inspire with a message of peace.9	Message: A universalist ideal clashing profoundly with the repressive reality of the host nation.
Political/Cultural Context	A democratic nation celebrating its culture on the world stage. Performance complicated by weather, not politics.	A politically polarized America post-2016 election. Performance seen as a subtle call for unity and LGBTQ+ rights.	An autocratic state using the event for “sportswashing” amidst a severe human rights crackdown.13
Critical & Public Reception	Performance praised for its artistry and cultural sensitivity.5 Live audience reaction was negative due to pre-recording.2	Overwhelmingly positive critical acclaim; cited as one of the best halftime shows ever.8 Massive commercial success.	Performance itself praised for vocal talent.10 The context of the performance was largely overshadowed by criticism of the host regime.

IV. From Universalism to Specificity: The Evolution of Gaga’s Diplomatic Artistry

The comparative analysis of these three performances reveals a distinct learning curve.

The strategy employed in Paris appears to be a direct and highly intelligent response to the lessons learned from the ethical quagmire of Baku.

It marks a deliberate shift away from broad, universalist statements toward a more nuanced and contextually aware form of artistic engagement.

A. The Politics of the Platform: Art as a Tool of Statecraft

Performing at a state-sponsored global event is an inherently political act.

Such occasions are frequently used by host nations as platforms for international public relations, and an artist’s presence can be instrumentalized, intentionally or not.

The Baku Games serve as a textbook case of “sportswashing,” a term for when a regime with a poor human rights record uses a high-profile sporting event to launder its international reputation.¹⁵

By hosting the games and attracting a global star like Lady Gaga, the Azerbaijani government sought to project an image of modernity and openness that directly contradicted the reality of its domestic repression.¹²

The cultural capital of the artist is transferred to the host, lending legitimacy and a celebratory air to what is, in essence, a state propaganda exercise.

B. The “Imagine” Gambit: A Lesson in Context

The decision to perform “Imagine” in Baku represents a particular strategic approach: the universalist gambit.

This strategy operates on the assumption that a powerful, positive, and universally understood message—like that of Lennon’s song—is strong enough to transcend its immediate context and impose its own meaning on an event.

The Baku performance demonstrates the profound failure of this assumption.

The process by which the song’s meaning was inverted is revealing.

First, the universalist strategy presupposes that the art’s message can operate independently of its environment.

The Baku case proves the opposite: a sufficiently toxic political context does not merely serve as a backdrop for the art; it actively absorbs, neutralizes, and ultimately co-opts the art’s message.

The performance of “Imagine” did not succeed in bringing a message of peace and human rights to the Azerbaijani regime.

Instead, the Azerbaijani regime successfully used the performance of “Imagine” to project a false image of itself to the world.

The lesson is stark and unavoidable: on the global political stage, context is not passive.

It is an active agent that fundamentally shapes, and can even reverse, artistic meaning.

A failure to account for this leads, at best, to a naive gesture and, at worst, to unwitting complicity in a disinformation campaign.

C. The Paris Strategy: A Culturally-Attuned Corrective

The performance at the Paris Olympics represents a paradigm shift in strategy, one seemingly born from the hard-won lessons of Baku.

It is a direct corrective to the failure of decontextualized idealism.

Instead of a universalist anthem applicable to any time or place, Lady Gaga chose a song that was deeply and specifically French.

Instead of attempting to impose an external message of her own, she engaged with and elevated an internal one from the host culture itself.

This strategy of “specificity” is far more robust and politically astute.

It is an act of cultural dialogue, not a monologue.

By meticulously researching French cabaret history, collaborating with a French fashion house, and paying detailed homage to a French icon like Zizi Jeanmaire, she demonstrated research, respect, and humility.³

This approach created a performance that was meaningful

to the host nation on its own terms.

Such a performance is far less vulnerable to the kind of political co-option seen in Baku because its meaning is intrinsically tied to the very culture it is celebrating.

It is a gesture that says, “I have taken the time to see you and understand your art,” rather than, “Here is a message I have brought for you.” This shift from abstract universalism to concrete cultural engagement marks a significant maturation in her approach to diplomatic artistry.

V. Conclusion: The Art of Global Stature

Lady Gaga performed at the Paris Olympics because she occupies that rare echelon of global stardom that makes one a candidate for such an honor.

But the deeper answer to “why” lies in how she performed.

Her decision to deliver a meticulously researched, culturally specific homage to France was a deliberate artistic and diplomatic choice, one that speaks volumes about her evolution as a performer on the world stage.

The performance showcased an artist who has moved beyond the brand consolidation of her triumphant Super Bowl show and, more significantly, has clearly absorbed the complex lessons from her appearance in Baku.

The Paris strategy reflects a mature understanding that the global stage is not a neutral platform.

It is a contested space where meaning is negotiated and where art can be easily instrumentalized.

The contrast is clear: where the universalist idealism of “Imagine” was swallowed by the political reality of its setting, the cultural specificity of “Mon Truc en Plumes” was an act of deference that fortified the performance against misinterpretation.

It was a gesture of respect that could only be read as intended: a tribute.

The performance on the Seine was the work of a legacy artist who has come to understand that on the world stage, the greatest power lies not in being heard, but in demonstrating that you have listened.

It was the culmination of a decade-long, high-stakes education in the art of global performance, proving that true influence is wielded not through grand, generic pronouncements, but through nuanced, intelligent, and respectful engagement with the cultures one is invited to address.

Works cited

1. Lady Gaga Performs ‘Mon Truc en Plumes’ at 2024 Summer …, accessed August 6, 2025, https://people.com/paris-olympics-2024-lady-gaga-opening-ceremony-performance-8684023
2. Why was Lady Gaga’s Olympics performance pre-recorded? | The …, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/news/lady-gaga-olympics-opening-ceremony-performance-b2588489.html
3. Lady Gaga Honors Zizi Jeanmaire in Olympic Opening Ceremony Performance – Extra, accessed August 6, 2025, https://extratv.com/2024/07/26/lady-gaga-honors-zizi-jeanmaire-in-olympic-opening-ceremony-performance/
4. Lady Gaga performs at Paris Olympics Opening Ceremony | NBC Sports – YouTube, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akC9tZ2k6ys
5. Lady Gaga recreates ‘Ed Sullivan Show’ moment with Paris Olympics performance, accessed August 6, 2025, https://ew.com/olympics-celine-dion-performance-lady-gaga-8683161
6. Mon truc en plumes – Sung by Lady Gaga at the Paris Olympics – FrenchLearner, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.frenchlearner.com/songs/mon-truc-en-plumes/
7. fi – Cairn, accessed August 6, 2025, https://shs.cairn.info/article/CLA_008_0073/pdf?lang=fr
8. Super Bowl LI halftime show – Wikipedia, accessed August 6, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_LI_halftime_show
9. Lady Gaga performs “Imagine” at the opening of European Games – All-Noise, accessed August 6, 2025, https://all-noise.co.uk/lady-gaga-performs-%E2%80%9Cimagine%E2%80%9D-at-the-opening-of-european-games/10925/
10. Lady Gaga Imagine Cover: The singer covers Lennon at the …, accessed August 6, 2025, https://slate.com/culture/2015/06/lady-gaga-imagine-cover-the-singer-covers-lennon-at-the-european-games-in-baku-azerbaijan-video.html
11. European Games Opening Ceremony highlights in pictures – NBC Sports, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.nbcsports.com/olympics/news/european-games-opening-ceremony-lady-gaga-imagine-pictures
12. Azerbaijan bans Guardian from reporting on Baku European Games, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2015/jun/11/azerbaijan-bans-guardian-european-games-baku-2015
13. Azerbaijan: Rights Crisis Overshadows European Games – Human Rights Watch, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/03/04/azerbaijan-rights-crisis-overshadows-european-games
14. The 2015 European Games in Azerbaijan: Human Rights Violations Already – TriplePundit, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2014/2015-european-games-azerbaijan-human-rights-violations-already/41446
15. Baku games are human rights ‘whitewash’ attempt by Azerbaijan government, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/news/article/baku-games-are-human-rights-whitewash-attempt-by-azerbaijan-government
16. European Games 2015 open in Azerbaijan amidst crackdown on human rights and media freedom, accessed August 6, 2025, https://www.mediasupport.org/european-games-2015-open-amidst-crackdown-freedom-expression-human-rights/