Through the Portal: An In-Depth Analysis of Melanie Martinez’s Artistic Rebirth

The Death of Cry Baby: A Narrative Imperative

The artistic shift undertaken by Melanie Martinez for her third studio album, Portals, was not a spontaneous reinvention but the calculated and narratively necessary culmination of a nearly decade-long story. The transition from the polished, pastel world of K-12 to the ethereal, grotesque realm of Portals is rooted in the deliberate conclusion of the Cry Baby character’s arc. This “death” serves as the fundamental plot point that bridges the two eras, framing the change as a matter of narrative imperative rather than a simple rebranding exercise.

The Final Scene of a Chapter

The direct catalyst for the Portals era is the final scene of Martinez’s 2019 feature film, K-12. After leading a supernatural rebellion and destroying the oppressive school system that served as the film’s setting, the character Cry Baby and her friends are met by their spirit guide, the angel-like Lilith.¹ Lilith beckons the group towards a mysterious doorway—a literal portal—leading to a spiritual realm.¹ The film concludes on a cliffhanger as Cry Baby hesitates, looking back before deciding whether to step through into the unknown.² This moment of indecision encapsulates a core theme of the subsequent album: the universal fear of transition and the passage from one state of being to another. The

Portals album and its accompanying visuals serve as the direct resolution to this cliffhanger, confirming that Cry Baby did indeed enter the portal, an act that resulted in the death of her earthly vessel.²

Completing the Trilogy of Life

Martinez has consistently framed her first three albums as a conceptual trilogy that chronicles a complete life cycle.² The debut album,

Cry Baby (2015), established the character and explored the traumas and discoveries of birth and early childhood through dark, nursery-rhyme-inflected pop.⁴ The follow-up,

K-12, represented the next stage of life, using the school environment as a multifaceted metaphor for adolescence, societal conditioning, and systemic power structures.² In this framework,

Portals (2023) logically serves as the final installment, mapping out the character’s death, her journey through the afterlife, and her eventual rebirth.⁵ Martinez herself has articulated this structure, explaining her intent to show the character’s journey from childhood, through a school-as-life analogy, and finally into the afterlife to demonstrate the concept of immortality.⁴ The death of Cry Baby was therefore the required final act to bring this ambitious, three-part narrative to its planned conclusion.

Symbolism of the Transition

The act of passing through the portal is laden with symbolism. It signifies that Cry Baby’s purpose within her human form was fulfilled upon the destruction of the K-12 Sleepaway School, an institution representing societal oppression.⁹ Her physical death is not presented as an end but as a profound transformation. She becomes a spirit, manifesting as the pink-skinned, four-eyed nymph-like creature that defines the

Portals era.⁹ This new form is the visual representation of her soul, now untethered from its earthly vessel and navigating a liminal space.² The promotional rollout for the album was explicit in signaling this narrative shift, featuring visuals of a mushroom with “RIP Cry Baby” carved into its stalk and changing all of her past YouTube thumbnails to an image of Cry Baby’s tombstone.¹ The 8 of Swords tarot card, symbolizing entrapment and the need to release old ways of thinking, was also used in the “DEATH” music video to signify the end of the character’s former self.¹⁵ This careful orchestration of symbols underscores that the change was a deeply considered narrative development. The ending of

K-12 was not an arbitrary conclusion but a carefully laid foundation for the next chapter. This suggests a level of long-term artistic foresight, positioning the death of Cry Baby not as a reaction to creative fatigue, but as the fulfillment of a story that was years in the making.

Metamorphosis: The Artist’s Evolution Beyond the Character

While the death of Cry Baby was a narrative necessity, it also coincided with and was propelled by Melanie Martinez’s own artistic and personal maturation. The Portals era is the manifestation of an artist shedding a persona created in her late teens to explore more complex, spiritual, and introspective themes that reflect her current identity. This evolution required a radical break from the past, not just in story but in the very relationship between the artist and her art.

Outgrowing the Cry Baby Persona

Martinez first conceptualized the Cry Baby character when she was 19 years old.¹⁶ By the release of

Portals, she was 27, and the aesthetic and thematic confines of the character she had inhabited for nearly a decade were becoming restrictive. Both fans and critics noted that the artist had matured and that a change was necessary to avoid creative stagnation.¹⁷ Some listeners felt the “kiddie/baby aesthetic” was already wearing thin by the end of the

Cry Baby era and that K-12, while more polished, amplified it to a degree that felt disconnected from an adult artist’s perspective.¹⁹ The shift to

Portals was a deliberate move to evolve beyond that persona and explore new genres and aesthetics while still honoring her commitment to storytelling.¹⁸ This artistic growth allowed her to address more adult themes without the filter of the childlike metaphor that defined her earlier work.²⁰

Separating Artist from Art

In her early career, Martinez noted the deep connection between herself and her character, stating, “I am Cry Baby”.²¹ This fusion was central to the project’s authenticity. The

Portals era, however, marks a conscious and dramatic separation of the artist from her creation. By completely obscuring her own face with intricate, full-body prosthetics for all public appearances—a process that can take up to two hours—Martinez forces the audience to engage with the art on its own terms.² This act challenges the modern celebrity culture that often prioritizes an artist’s personal life and appearance over their work, a phenomenon Martinez has previously expressed a desire to avoid.²² The mask and costume serve as a shield, protecting her private identity and re-centering the public’s focus on the conceptual world she has built.²⁴ This physical transformation paradoxically allows for a more profound form of personal expression. By removing her recognizable face, Martinez liberates herself from the expectations and scrutiny tied to her public image. This freedom enables her to delve into her most vulnerable and introspective lyrical work to date, as the art is no longer filtered through the public’s perception of “Melanie Martinez” but through the vessel of “The Creature.” The death of the old persona was a prerequisite for the birth of her most emotionally raw and honest music.¹

A Shift from External Critique to Internal Exploration

The thematic focus of Martinez’s work has undergone a significant evolution. Her first two albums were largely centered on external social critiques, viewed through the allegorical lens of childhood and adolescence. Cry Baby tackled issues of family dysfunction, alcoholism, and body image ³, while

K-12 expanded this critique to systemic issues within education, politics, and patriarchal power structures.²

Portals, in contrast, marks a profound turn inward. The album’s primary concerns are not societal ills but existential and spiritual questions of self-judgment, trauma, healing, and the nature of consciousness.¹ This reflects the artistic development of a creator moving from observing and critiquing the world around her to exploring the complex universe within herself.

The End of the Trilogy, The Start of a New Chapter

Martinez has been unequivocal in stating that Portals is the definitive end of the Cry Baby trilogy.¹⁰ She has confirmed that her next musical project will be a “completely new thing,” separate from the narrative and characters of her first three albums.¹⁰ This declaration solidifies the purpose of the

Portals era as a final, transformative act. “Killing” the character was a necessary step to close a nearly decade-long chapter of her career. This provides her with the artistic freedom to create entirely new worlds, potentially exploring more directly autobiographical themes, similar to the more personal nature of her 2020 EP, After School.²⁴

The Architecture of the Afterlife: Lyrical Themes and Sonic Worlds of Portals

The core of the Portals era is defined by a radical overhaul of Melanie Martinez’s thematic and sonic palettes. The album is a meticulously crafted concept piece, drawing from specific spiritual philosophies to build a narrative of the afterlife. This new conceptual framework is supported by a significant evolution in her lyrical style and a musical shift away from the dark electropop of her past toward a more aggressive and organic art-rock sound.

Primary Influence: Past life Regression Therapy

The conceptual architecture of Portals is explicitly drawn from Martinez’s personal research into past life regression hypnotherapy books, which she studied for four years leading up to the album’s creation.⁴ The album’s tracklist is structured to mirror the distinct phases of the afterlife journey as described in transcripts from hypnotherapy sessions.¹

• “DEATH”: The opening track establishes the album’s central premise of immortality. It represents the soul’s separation from its physical form, articulated in the lyric, “My body has died but I’m still alive”.¹ The song’s outro, featuring sounds of heavy breathing and running footsteps, signifies the spirit’s frantic entry into the next plane.³⁰
• “VOID”: This track corresponds directly to a commonly described stage in the afterlife: a liminal, dark space where the soul is left in total isolation to confront and judge itself without external influence.²⁸ The lyrics powerfully capture this state of intense self-criticism: “Like a priest behind confession walls, I judge myself, kneelin’ on a metal grater”.¹
• “LIGHT SHOWER”: This song represents a subsequent phase of spiritual cleansing. Martinez describes this concept as a place where “gem-colored rays of light shine through every inch of your soul, cleansing your spirit of the trauma it had experienced”.¹
• “WOMB”: As the album’s final track, “WOMB” depicts the soul’s preparation for rebirth into a new physical vessel.² The album is designed as a continuous loop, with the final words of “WOMB” (“Life is death is life is death is life, is—”) leading seamlessly back into the opening words of “DEATH” (“Death is life is death is life is death is life is”), reinforcing the central theme of a never-ending cycle.⁵

Lyrical Maturation and Complexity

The songwriting on Portals demonstrates a marked evolution from the more direct, allegorical style of previous albums. Where Cry Baby used childhood objects like a “Sippy Cup” to discuss alcoholism, Portals employs more nuanced and layered metaphors.²⁰ Many songs operate on a dual-meaning system, simultaneously advancing the afterlife narrative while also addressing tangible, real-world issues. For instance, “VOID” functions as both a depiction of a spiritual limbo and a raw exploration of anxiety and self-doubt.²⁸ Similarly, “SPIDER WEB” uses the imagery of being caught in a web to critique the addictive and constricting nature of social media.² This increased complexity requires a deeper level of engagement from the listener and reflects a more mature and sophisticated lyrical approach.²⁰

Processing Personal History

While her previous work was inspired by personal feelings, Portals is notable for being Martinez’s most direct engagement with specific events in her personal life. Several tracks are widely understood to be commentaries on her past high-profile relationship with musician Oliver Tree.

• “MOON CYCLE”: This track is a direct and defiant response to lyrics from Tree’s song “Revival,” in which he raps, “I’m angry and bloody like a b*tch on her period”.¹ Martinez reclaims this narrative, countering with lines like, “I could win a fight on my period. Matter of fact, right now, I could build a pyramid”.¹⁵ The song serves as both a personal rebuttal and a broader critique of the societal stigma surrounding menstruation.⁵
• “BATTLE OF THE LARYNX” and “EVIL”: These songs explore the dynamics of a toxic relationship, with Martinez having confirmed that “EVIL” is about a past partner.¹⁷ The tracks delve into themes of gaslighting, emotional manipulation, and the empowerment found in walking away from a destructive situation.² Martinez described wanting the lyrics for “EVIL” to be “the most savage,” reflecting a cathartic release of anger.¹⁴

Sonic Evolution: From Dark Pop to Art Rock

The thematic maturation of Portals is mirrored by a dramatic sonic shift. The album largely abandons the low-key hip-hop and electropop textures that characterized Cry Baby and K-12.³⁶ Instead, it embraces a sound best described as alternative art-pop and art-rock, with prominent elements of grunge and experimental pop.³⁰ The production is more organic and aggressive, featuring heavy basslines, fuzz-toned electric guitars, and powerful live drumming, with several tracks including contributions from Nine Inch Nails drummer Ilan Rubin.¹ This move towards a rock-oriented soundscape provides a fitting backdrop for the album’s darker, more intense, and emotionally raw lyrical content, marking a significant step outside of her previous sonic comfort zone.³⁷

Table 1: The Evolution of Melanie Martinez’s Eras

Feature	Cry Baby Era	K-12 Era	Portals Era
Narrative Stage	Birth & Childhood	Adolescence & Societal Indoctrination	Death, Afterlife & Rebirth
Core Persona	Insecure, vulnerable child	Empowered, rebellious student	Ethereal, introspective spirit (“The Creature”)
Visual Aesthetic	Pastel, vintage, infantile, doll-like	Coquettish schoolgirl, dark academia, polished	Mystical, grotesque, fairy-grunge, ethereal, nature-based
Musical Style	Dark-pop, electropop	Alternative pop, low-key hip-hop	Art-rock, experimental pop, grunge, synth-pop
Key Lyrical Themes	Family trauma, first love, insecurity	Systemic oppression, friendship, body image, bullying	Immortality, spirituality, self-reflection, toxic love, rebirth
Metaphorical Lens	Childhood objects (e.g., “Sippy Cup,” “Carousel”)	School environment (e.g., “The Principal,” “Detention”)	Spiritual/Natural concepts (e.g., “VOID,” “SPIDER WEB,” “WOMB”)

Visions from the Void: Crafting the Portals Aesthetic

The transition to the Portals era is defined by a comprehensive and radical visual rebranding. This aesthetic overhaul is not merely decorative; it is a core component of the album’s narrative and thematic identity. From the introduction of a new otherworldly persona to the adoption of a “fairy grunge” visual language, every element is designed to immerse the audience in the album’s conceptual world of death, rebirth, and spiritual transformation.

The Creature Persona

At the heart of the Portals aesthetic is Martinez’s new on-stage and public persona: a pink-skinned, four-eyed, ethereal creature with large, pointed ears and fairy-like features.⁵ This being is the physical manifestation of Cry Baby’s soul or her “true form” as it exists in the liminal space between death and new life.² While officially designated “The Creature” on merchandise, fans have adopted various other names such as “nymph,” “fae,” “sprite,” or “alien,” all of which underscore its otherworldly and mystical nature.⁴⁰ Martinez’s commitment to this persona is total; she wears full-body prosthetics, custom contact lenses, and elaborate makeup for all public appearances, including concerts, interviews, and even fan meet-and-greets.¹⁶ The application process is extensive, requiring between one and a half to two hours to complete, demonstrating a profound dedication to maintaining the immersive illusion of the character.²³

Aesthetic Shift from Pastel to Ethereal Grunge

The visual language of Portals represents a stark departure from the coquettish, vintage-inspired pastel aesthetic that defined the Cry Baby and K-12 eras.¹⁷ The new style is darker, more organic, and grotesque, drawing from a visual palette that fans and critics have described as “fairy grunge,” “ethereal,” or “grunge cottagecore”.¹⁷ The imagery is dominated by elements of a magical, and at times decaying, natural world: moss, giant mushrooms, mystical forests, and surreal landscapes.²⁹ This aesthetic choice has drawn comparisons to the avant-garde visuals of artists like Björk, particularly her work on the album

Fossora, signifying a move toward a more experimental and less conventionally “pop” visual identity.³⁴ The decision to embrace a “grotesque” or “creepy” look over a more traditionally beautiful fairy figure is a deliberate artistic statement. It challenges the aesthetic norms of pop music and aligns directly with the album’s core themes. The raw, uncomfortable, and sometimes “ugly” truths explored in the lyrics—self-hatred in “VOID,” the biology of menstruation in “MOON CYCLE”—are mirrored in the creature’s physically monstrous appearance. By abandoning conventional prettiness, Martinez achieves a deeper form of authenticity where her visual form is in perfect synergy with her lyrical content.

Music Videos as Standalone Representations

The approach to music videos has also evolved. While the Cry Baby era featured a series of narratively interconnected videos and K-12 was presented as a single, feature-length film, the visuals for Portals are conceived as individual, artistic representations of each song’s core theme rather than as sequential plot points.¹¹ This strategy grants Martinez greater artistic freedom, allowing a video’s concept to diverge from the song’s literal lyrical content. A prime example is the music video for “TUNNEL VISION,” which pivots from the song’s theme of objectification to a meta-commentary on obsessive fan culture.¹¹ Martinez has indicated that the complete, linear narrative of the

Portals story is being reserved for a planned feature film, which was scripted alongside the album’s creation.¹¹ This allows the music videos to function as standalone visual poems, exploring specific facets of the album’s world without the constraint of advancing a rigid plot.

Reception and Legacy: A Dialogue with the ‘Earthlings’

The radical artistic departure of the Portals era has elicited a complex and polarized response from both fans and critics. This shift has served to simultaneously invigorate a segment of her audience while alienating another, repositioning Martinez as a more ambitious and challenging figure in the landscape of alternative pop. The dialogue surrounding the album, particularly concerning the new persona, has become a meta-narrative that reflects the very themes of perception and evolution that the work itself explores.

Fan Reception: A Divided Kingdom

The fanbase, whom Martinez began addressing as “Earthlings” during this era, has been notably divided in its reception.²⁸

• Praise and Connection: A large contingent of listeners has embraced Portals as Martinez’s magnum opus. They celebrate it as her most mature, lyrically complex, and sonically adventurous project to date, viewing the evolution as a sign of profound artistic growth.¹⁶ These fans connect deeply with the spiritual and existential themes, interpreting the album as a powerful and immersive journey of healing and self-discovery.³⁵ For many who have grown up alongside Martinez, the album’s focus on adult themes of self-reflection and navigating toxic relationships resonates more strongly than the childhood allegories of her past work.²⁰
• Criticism and Alienation: Conversely, a significant portion of the established fanbase has expressed feelings of disconnection and disappointment. Many mourn the loss of the Cry Baby character and the associated pastel aesthetic, finding the new creature persona to be unsettling or “creepy”.¹⁷ A primary point of contention is Martinez’s decision to completely hide her face behind prosthetics, with some fans feeling a loss of personal connection to the artist they had followed for years.¹⁷ Others find the new musical direction to be sonically monotonous or less relatable than the more direct storytelling of her previous albums.¹³

Critical Reception: Acknowledging Ambition

Professional critical reception has been similarly mixed, though most reviews acknowledge the project’s immense ambition and artistic risk.

• Positive Reviews: Publications such as Rolling Stone praised the album as an “effortlessly inventive, mature record,” noting that Martinez used the new alter-ego to deliver her “most introspective lyrics and sounds that move outside her sonic comfort zone”.³⁰ Others commended
  Portals as a “statement of rebirth” and praised the successful integration of new, harsher rock and grunge tones into her established sound.³⁰
• Mixed and Negative Reviews: Some critics found the reinvention to be only partially successful. The Line of Best Fit argued that while the lyrical themes were darker and more “real,” the album too often retreated to melodies and instrumentation “remarkably similar to her past work,” failing to fully realize the promised reinvention.³⁰ Several reviewers, including the
  Evening Standard and Exclaim!, drew comparisons to Björk, suggesting Martinez’s version of avant-garde visuals and nature-based themes was less adventurous and more derivative.³⁰

The Meta-Narrative of Fan Expectations

The intense fan debate over Martinez’s new appearance creates a compelling meta-narrative. The frustration expressed by some fans over her hidden face and their desire to see the “real” Melanie directly mirrors the album’s lyrical themes of being objectified and misunderstood, as explored in songs like “TUNNEL VISION” and “NYMPHOLOGY”.² This dynamic suggests that the artistic shift of the

Portals era functions as a kind of “fandom filter.” The radical departure from a beloved and commercially successful aesthetic acts as a deliberate challenge to the audience. It tests whether their loyalty is to a static product—the Cry Baby persona—or to the evolving artist herself. This forces listeners to either grow with Martinez and embrace her new direction or remain attached to a past era, effectively curating a core audience that is invested in her ongoing artistic journey, however unconventional it may be.

Conclusion: Beyond the Rebirth

The shift to the Portals era was a multifaceted and deliberate artistic evolution, driven by a confluence of narrative, personal, and creative imperatives. It was not a simple change in costume or sound but a comprehensive reinvention of Melanie Martinez’s identity as a recording artist. The decision was, first and foremost, the necessary conclusion to the planned trilogy that began with Cry Baby, bringing the character’s life-cycle narrative to its logical and symbolic end.

Simultaneously, this narrative finale provided the vehicle for Martinez’s own personal and artistic maturation. It allowed her to shed a persona created in her youth and explore more complex, adult themes that reflect her own spiritual interests and personal growth. The adoption of the “Creature” persona and the complete obscuring of her face was a radical act of separating the artist from the art, a move that paradoxically enabled her to produce her most vulnerable and introspective work to date. This was accompanied by a significant sonic and aesthetic overhaul, moving from dark electropop and pastel visuals to a more aggressive art-rock sound and a “fairy grunge” aesthetic that mirrored the album’s raw, mystical, and often grotesque themes.

Ultimately, the Portals era serves a crucial dual function. It provides a definitive and dramatic closure to the nearly decade-long Cry Baby saga, a story that defined the first phase of her career and cultivated a dedicated global fanbase. At the same time, the album acts as a “portal” for Martinez herself, liberating her from the creative confines of her past persona and opening the door to a new chapter of artistic freedom. Having concluded the trilogy, Martinez has confirmed her intention to pursue entirely new concepts, separate from the Cry Baby universe.¹⁰

Portals therefore stands as a pivotal and transformative bridge, an ambitious and polarizing work that not only concludes a beloved story but also signals the rebirth of its creator, leaving both the artist and her audience poised on the threshold of a new and unknown future.

Works cited

1. Melanie Martinez “Portals” – Breaking Down the Space Between Death and Life, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.musicscenemedia.com/melanie-martinez-portals-breaking-down-the-space-between-death-and-life/
2. Melanie Martinez ‘Portals’ album analysis, review – The Rocky Mountain Collegian, accessed August 12, 2025, https://collegian.com/articles/aande/2023/04/category-arts-and-entertainment-melanie-martinez-portals-album-analysis-and-review/
3. Melanie Martinez and the Dynamics of her Cry Baby Trilogy – MUSIC SCENE MEDIA, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.musicscenemedia.com/melanie-martinez-and-the-dynamics-of-her-cry-baby-trilogy/
4. Melanie Martinez Breaks Down Her Eras – TikTok, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.tiktok.com/@thebigreidshow/video/7246943688830635306
5. Melanie Martinez enters a new era in ‘PORTALS’ – El Estoque, accessed August 12, 2025, https://elestoque.org/2023/04/04/entertainment/melanie-martinez-enters-a-new-era-in-portals/
6. The Complex Story of Melanie Martinez’ Cry Baby – The Lincolnian, accessed August 12, 2025, https://lincolnian.net/3044/arts/the-complex-story-of-melanie-martinez-cry-baby-a-review-of-melanie-martinez-cry-baby/
7. Melanie Martinez’s “Portals”: A Disappointing Last Album – The Issaquah High Times, accessed August 12, 2025, https://ihsjournalism.online/6505/showcase/melanie-martinezs-portals-a-disappointing-last-album/
8. ‘Portals’ brings Martinez’s ‘Crybaby’ era to a disappointing end – The Purbalite, accessed August 12, 2025, https://purbalite.net/27272/entertainment/portals-brings-martinezs-crybaby-era-to-a-disappointing-end/
9. Could someone explain the lore for her recent album? : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/1be07do/could_someone_explain_the_lore_for_her_recent/
10. I asked @Melanie Martinez if “Cry Baby” was ever coming back.. #melani… | TikTok, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.tiktok.com/@thebigreidshow/video/7246900761299373354
11. About the plot of PORTALS : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/1aonunm/about_the_plot_of_portals/
12. Review: A portal into Melanie Martinez’s new album – ethic news, accessed August 12, 2025, https://ethic-news.org/2023/04/28/review-a-portal-into-melanie-martinezs-new-album/
13. End of the “Crybaby” Trilogy: Melanie Martinez “PORTALS” review – The Zephyr, accessed August 12, 2025, https://wfhszephyr.com/5346/opinion/end-of-the-crybaby-trilogy-melanie-martinez-portals-review/
14. PORTALS: A New Era For Melanie Martinez – UMass Dartmouth’s Student Newspaper, accessed August 12, 2025, https://umassdtorch.com/2023/04/14/portals-a-new-era-for-melanie-martinez/
15. “PORTALS” Marks the Beginning of a New Era for Melanie Martinez …, accessed August 12, 2025, https://tiffinblaze.squarespace.com/reviews/p3xi6dnmns0bxs9r7sf9r47sb7neq8
16. Portals is Melanie Martinez’s best album – The Playwickian, accessed August 12, 2025, https://playwickian.com/10603/op-ed/portals-is-melanie-martinezs-best-album/
17. Martinez embodies performance art through ‘portals’ of creative …, accessed August 12, 2025, http://www.oshkoshwestindex.org/entertainment-vol-119-issue-vii/2023/4/24/martinez-embodies-performance-art-through-portals-of-creative-transcendence
18. Why was Crybaby killed off? : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/16cjvz4/why_was_crybaby_killed_off/
19. Melanie Martinez starts a new era and teases the death of her character “Cry Baby”. – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/popheads/comments/115eg23/melanie_martinez_starts_a_new_era_and_teases_the/
20. HOT TAKE ‼️‼️ PORTALS IS MELANIES BEST ALBUM LYRICALLY : r/MelanieMartinez, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/1idpbdr/hot_take_portals_is_melanies_best_album_lyrically/
21. the dollhouse: In conversation with ‘Cry Baby’ artist Melanie Martinez – HelloGiggles, accessed August 12, 2025, https://hellogiggles.com/melanie-martinez-crybaby-interview/
22. LADYGUNN – Melanie Martinez is More Than A Cry Baby, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.ladygunn.com/music/melanie-martinez-is-more-than-a-cry-baby/
23. melanie martinez on open house party discussing her album “PORTALS” (unpitched ver.) ‍♀️ – YouTube, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bRrXdE_MkiM
24. About the PORTALS era : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/17qgo9a/about_the_portals_era/
25. crybaby or k-12? : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/19chucv/crybaby_or_k12/
26. What if I told you that PORTALS is Melanie Martinez’s 4th Album, Not her 3rd. Let me explain. : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/15bdtn8/what_if_i_told_you_that_portals_is_melanie/
27. Theory about what Portals is about. : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/1jk6lto/theory_about_what_portals_is_about/
28. Melanie from the interview for Apple Music, revealing the “Portals” al… – TikTok, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.tiktok.com/@melaniemusicvideo/video/7216215151136083206
29. Melanie Martinez has made her return to music with new ‘PORTALS’ album – AS USA, accessed August 12, 2025, https://en.as.com/entertainment/melanie-martinez-has-made-her-return-to-music-with-new-portals-album-n/
30. Portals (Melanie Martinez album) – Wikipedia, accessed August 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portals_(Melanie_Martinez_album)
31. Melanie Martinez PORTALS album review – a psychedelic trip to a new dimension., accessed August 12, 2025, https://brignews.com/2023/04/03/melanie-martinez-portals-album-review-a-psychedelic-trip-to-a-new-dimension/
32. REVIEW: Melanie Martinez’s ‘Portals’ weaves effects with musical storytelling – Frederick Community College’s Student-Run Newspaper, accessed August 12, 2025, https://thecommuter.org/2023/04/review-melanie-martinezs-portals-weaves-effects-with-musical-storytelling/
33. Review of Melanie Martinez’s “PORTALS” – The Mission, accessed August 12, 2025, https://smnmission.com/uncategorized/2023/05/23/review-of-melanie-martinezs-portals/
34. Melanie Martinez: PORTALS review – a halfway-there attempt at reinvention, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.thelineofbestfit.com/albums/melanie-martinez-portals-halfway-there-attempt-at-reinvention
35. Why do some of y’all think portals is the weakest album?/gen : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/13w55si/why_do_some_of_yall_think_portals_is_the_weakest/
36. K–12 (album) – Wikipedia, accessed August 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%E2%80%9312_(album)
37. Back From The Dead – Demo Magazine, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.demomagazine.ca/blog/portals-by-melanie-martinez-review
38. en.wikipedia.org, accessed August 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portals_(Melanie_Martinez_album)#:~:text=Critical%20reception,-Professional%20ratings&text=Rolling%20Stone%20writer%20Tom%C3%A1s%20Mier,outside%20her%20sonic%20comfort%20zone%22.
39. Review: Melanie Martinez album ‘PORTALS’ stuns fans – The Poly Post, accessed August 12, 2025, https://thepolypost.com/arts-and-culture/2023/04/25/review-melanie-martinez-album-portals-stuns-fans/
40. Does this “character” have a name? : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/16kh3rt/does_this_character_have_a_name/
41. Melanie Martinez Official Store | Merch, Music, Albums, Vinyl, CDs, accessed August 12, 2025, https://store.melaniemartinezmusic.com/
42. Portals Creature All-Over T-Shirt – Melanie Martinez, accessed August 12, 2025, https://store.melaniemartinezmusic.com/products/portals-creature-all-over-t-shirt
43. Exploring the Aesthetic of Melanie Martinez’s PORTALS Album – Lemon8 App, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.lemon8-app.com/@tisheyana2/7321398351416640005?region=us
44. 86 Melanie Martinez Portals aesthetic ideas in 2025 – Pinterest, accessed August 12, 2025, https://uk.pinterest.com/antoniorigolli/melanie-martinez-portals-aesthetic/
45. What is PORTALS’s “aesthetic”? : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/1heu4l8/what_is_portalss_aesthetic/
46. Melanie Martinez Void Aesthetic – Pinterest, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.pinterest.com/ideas/melanie-martinez-void-aesthetic/893642325304/
47. Melanie Martinez, Portals album review: back to nature in a delightfully weird way, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.standard.co.uk/culture/music/melanie-martinez-portals-album-review-b1071085.html
48. What portals means to me… : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/18ms5pt/what_portals_means_to_me/
49. Everything about PORTALS is really… weird… : r/MelanieMartinez – Reddit, accessed August 12, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/MelanieMartinez/comments/18fxi55/everything_about_portals_is_really_weird/